Ishmael and the House of God

Some scholars interpret the phrase “God was with the lad” from Genesis 21:20 to imply that Abraham left Ishmael and Hagar near the House of God (Kaaba) and dedicated them to God, as mentioned in the Quran, Surah 14, verse 37. They also believe the phrase “and he grew” in Genesis 21:20 indicates that Ishmael was still an infant at that time. What are their reasoning and arguments?

Here are the key arguments and reasoning behind this particular scholarly interpretation:

1. Analysis of "God was with the lad" (Genesis 21:20):

These scholars argue that this phrase indicates more than just divine protection - it suggests a specific sacred location. They connect this with Surah 14, verse 37, of the Quran where Abraham states: "O our Lord! I have settled some of my offspring in an uncultivated valley near Your Sacred House". The parallel between these texts is seen as evidence that Ishmael was left near the Kaaba (House of God), where God's presence would be particularly manifest.

2. Ishmael’s Age and the Phrase “And He Grew”:

The phrase “and he grew” suggests a developmental stage, implying that Ishmael was still a young child or infant when these events occurred. This is consistent with the narrative in Genesis 21, where Hagar carries the child and later places him under a shrub when they run out of water. In Islamic texts, Ishmael is depicted as an infant during the journey to Mecca. The miracle of the Zamzam well, which sprang forth to provide water for Hagar and Ishmael, is a central story illustrating God’s care for them in their vulnerability.

3. Theological Framework:

These scholars view the story as part of a larger narrative of divine purpose. Abraham's action is interpreted not as abandonment but as a divinely guided placement. The location near the Kaaba is seen as crucial for Ishmael's future role in establishing monotheistic worship there.

4. Textual Connections:

The scholars draw parallels between the biblical account and Quranic narrative. They see the biblical phrase "God was with the lad" as complementary to the Quranic account of Abraham settling his family near God's Sacred House. The emphasis on divine presence in both texts is viewed as supporting this interpretation.

This interpretation represents a particular scholarly view that attempts to harmonize biblical and Quranic accounts, though it's important to note that this is one of several interpretations of these texts.

Sacred Cities in Islam: The Sanctification of Mecca, Medina, and the Holy Land Of Palestine

Scholars argue that Mecca attained its sacred status through Abraham's prayer, while Medina became sacred through Muhammad's supplication, and the Holy Land of Palestine was declared sacred by God Himself, as mentioned in Surah 21, verse 71. How is this viewpoint presented?

The viewpoint that Mecca, Medina, and the Holy Land of Palestine attained their sacred statuses through different means is rooted in Islamic tradition and scripture. According to this perspective:

1. Mecca's Sacred Status through Abraham's Prayer: It is believed in Islamic tradition that Mecca gained its sacredness through the prayers of Abraham. This is linked to the story of Abraham and his son Ishmael in the Islamic narrative, where they rebuilt the Kaaba, and Abraham's subsequent prayer for the people of Mecca.

2. Medina's Sacred Status through Muhammad's Supplication: Medina (formerly Yathrib) became sacred in Islam primarily due to its association with the Prophet Muhammad. It is where he migrated to (known as the Hijra), a pivotal event in Islamic history. The Prophet's presence, his establishment of a Muslim community there, and his supplications contributed to Medina's sanctity.

3. The Holy Land of Palestine's Sacred Status Declared by God: The sacred status of the Holy Land, which includes Jerusalem, is believed to be directly declared by God. This is supported by references in the Quran, such as in Surah 21, verse 71, which alludes to the land's sanctity.

Allah says: "And We saved him [Abraham] and Lot to the land which We have blessed for the worlds."

This area holds significant religious importance in Islam due to its association with various prophets and as the site of the Al-Aqsa Mosque, which is linked to the Prophet Muhammad's Night Journey.

This viewpoint is represented in Islamic teachings and is often discussed in the context of the religious and historical significance of these cities in Islam. It highlights the spiritual and historical connections that Muslims have with these cities, each with its unique religious significance.

Examine “Baca” in Psalm 84, verse 6, and “Bakkah” of Surah 3, verse 96, from the Quran. How do they correlate?

An excerpt from Holman Concise Bible Dictionary about Baca in Psalm 84, verse 6:
Baca
(Balsam tree or weeping)
Valley in Psalm 84, verse 6, which reflects a poetic play on words describing a person forced to go through a time of weeping who found that God turned tears into a well, providing water.

Baca, mentioned in Psalm 84, verse 6, is believed to be Mecca, which Surah 3, verse 96 of the Quran refers to as Bakkah. It was Hagar, the mother of Ishmael, who was forced to experience a period of weeping, who discovered that God had turned tears into a miraculous well of Zamzam. What is the articulation of this argument?

The argument you've presented draws a connection between two distinct religious texts, the Bible and the Quran, by referencing similar concepts found within both. The statement juxtaposes the poetic description from Psalm 84, verse 6, in the Bible, which mentions the Valley of Baca (often interpreted as a place of weeping or sorrow), with a narrative from the Quran.

According to Surah 3, verse 96, the Quran mentions a place called Bakkah, identified by many scholars and tradition as Mecca, a city of paramount importance in Islam.

The biblical excerpt describes a metaphorical transformation where a time of weeping is turned into a source of sustenance and blessing, symbolized by tears turning into a well. This metaphor captures the idea of divine intervention and support during times of distress, providing not just relief but also nourishment and strength from the adversity faced.

The Quranic reference complements this biblical narrative by recounting the story of Hagar and Ishmael, where Hagar's desperate search for water in the desert for her infant son Ishmael is rewarded by the miraculous appearance of the Zamzam well. This story is deeply embedded in Islamic tradition and highlights themes of faith, divine provision, and the transformation of despair into hope.

By articulating this argument, the connection being made is that both biblical and Quranic texts, while from different religious traditions, reflect a similar theological theme: the belief in a benevolent deity who transforms moments of deep personal despair into opportunities for divine blessing and providence.

The comparison suggests a shared motif of spiritual testing and divine intervention, where the act of enduring hardship with faith can lead to miraculous outcomes, symbolized through the provision of water in both narratives. This water, whether from the well mentioned in Psalm 84, verse 6, or the Zamzam well in Islamic tradition, stands as a powerful symbol of life, sustenance, and the transformative power of faith.

Abraham and the House of God in Jerusalem and Mecca

Did Moses and Abraham know that the temple would be built in Jerusalem?

The Bible does not explicitly state that Moses and Abraham knew about the future construction of the Temple in Jerusalem. However, both figures are significant in the Jewish tradition regarding the covenant with God and the eventual establishment of a central place of worship.

1. Abraham: He is often associated with the land of Canaan, which includes Jerusalem. The biblical narrative highlights that he established altars and worshiped God in various locations, symbolizing a connection to the land that would later become significant in Jewish history.

2. Moses: He led the Israelites out of Egypt and received the Law at Mount Sinai. His connection to the Tabernacle, a mobile sanctuary, is significant, as it laid the groundwork for central worship in the future. The establishment of the Temple in Jerusalem is often viewed as a fulfillment of the promise of a permanent dwelling place for God, but there is no direct indication that Moses was aware of the future Temple.

In Jewish tradition, the idea of a Temple in Jerusalem is connected to prophecies and promises made later in the biblical narrative, particularly during the time of King David and Solomon. Therefore, while Moses and Abraham played crucial roles in the religious history of the Israelites, there is no definitive evidence that Moses and Abraham had knowledge of the Temple's future construction.

How is Abraham linked to the Kaaba (House of God) in Mecca in Islam?

In Islam, Abraham is deeply connected to the Kaaba in Mecca, which is regarded as the House of God. According to Islamic tradition:

1. Construction of the Kaaba: It is believed that Abraham, along with his son Ishmael, was instructed by God to build the Kaaba as a place of worship. The Kaaba is considered the first house of worship dedicated to the monotheistic belief in one God.

2. Covenant and Submission: Abraham is viewed as a key figure in Islam for his unwavering submission to God's will and his role as a prophet. His dedication to monotheism is foundational to Islamic beliefs.

3. Pilgrimage (Hajj): The Kaaba is the focal point of the Hajj pilgrimage, one of the Five Pillars of Islam. Muslims from around the world perform rituals around the Kaaba, commemorating the actions of Abraham and Ishmael.

4.Significance of the Black Stone: The Black Stone (Hajar al-Aswad), set into the corner of the Kaaba, is said to have been given to Abraham by the angel Gabriel. It is revered by Muslims as a sacred object.

Overall, Abraham's legacy as a prophet and the father of monotheism links him to the Kaaba (House of God), reinforcing the importance of the site in Islamic faith and practice.

Islam as the Restoration of Abraham’s Original Teachings

Islam is considered a restored religion of Abraham, based on the perspective that both Judaism and Christianity have deviated from his original teachings.
Adherents of Islam assert that Judaism has altered the command regarding the sacrifice of Abraham's son, holding that the son in question was Ishmael rather than Isaac.

Furthermore, they contend that Christianity has diverged from the tenet of monotheism by introducing the concept of the Trinity and modifying the practice of circumcision.
Therefore, from the Islamic viewpoint, Islam embodies the authentic restoration of the teachings of Abraham as presented in the Quran.

The Western Wall, the Dome of the Rock and the Jewish Temple


Which location is considered more sacred according to rabbinic ruling: the Western Wall or the area where the Dome of the Rock currently exists?

According to rabbinic ruling, the area where the Dome of the Rock currently exists is considered more sacred than the Western Wall. The Dome of the Rock is located on the Temple Mount, which is traditionally viewed as the holiest site in Judaism, as it is believed to be the location of the ancient Jewish temples.

The Western Wall, while a very significant and sacred site for prayer and the Jewish people, is considered a remnant of the Second Temple and thus holds a different level of sanctity compared to the Temple Mount itself.

What is a considerable obstacle to the Jews to rebuild their temple in Jerusalem?

A considerable obstacle to the Jews rebuilding their temple in Jerusalem is the current presence of the Al-Aqsa Mosque and the Dome of the Rock, two of the holiest sites in Islam. Both structures are located on the Temple Mount (known as Haram al-Sharif in Islam), which is traditionally believed to be the location of the First and Second Jewish Temples.

Some Islamic scholars assert that Muhammad's Night Journey to Jerusalem, which resulted in the establishment of the Dome of the Rock and Al Aqsa Mosque to honor this event, effectively nullifies the sacrificial practices of Judaism. In contrast, Christians hold that it was through Jesus' crucifixion on the cross that such practices were superseded.