Does Christianity view praying to anyone other than God as a form of idolatry?
In Christianity, prayer should predominantly be directed to God; however, it is common for Christians to ask saints or the Virgin Mary to intercede on their behalf. This isn't considered praying "to" them, but rather asking for their intercession. These practices can vary between different denominations. Engaging in prayer to anyone or anything considered non-divine, in a way that attributes divine power or character to them, could be considered a form of idolatry in many Christian perspectives.
--------
What is Protestantism's perspective on the practice of seeking the intercession of saints or the Virgin Mary in prayer within Catholicism?
Protestantism generally rejects the practice of seeking the intercession of saints or the Virgin Mary in prayer, which is a common practice in Catholicism. This is rooted in several key theological differences between the two branches of Christianity.
1. Scripture Alone: One of the key tenets of Protestant theology is "Sola Scriptura," or "Scripture Alone." Protestants believe that all necessary truths for salvation and living a Christian life are contained within the Bible. Since the Bible does not explicitly mention praying to saints or the Virgin Mary for their intercession, Protestants generally view this practice as non-Biblical.
2. Mediator: Another key belief in Protestant theology is that Jesus Christ is the sole mediator between God and humans. They often cite verses like 1 Timothy 2:5: “For there is one God and one mediator between God and mankind, the man Christ Jesus." In this view, asking the saints or the Virgin Mary for their intercession is unnecessary and detracts from the role of Christ.
3. Saints: While Protestants do acknowledge the concept of sainthood, they generally believe that all believers are saints, as opposed to the Catholic tradition of canonizing specific individuals.
4. Idolatry: Some Protestants also view praying to saints as a form of idolatry, since they argue it places created beings on a level with God.
However, it's important to note that Protestantism is a diverse branch of Christianity with many different subgroups, and beliefs on this topic can vary. Some Anglicans and Lutherans, for example, maintain a more traditional view about intercession of saints than do most other Protestants.
---------
Does Judaism view praying to anyone other than God as a form of idolatry?
Yes, in Judaism, prayer is exclusively directed to God. Praying to anyone or anything else is seen as idolatry, which is strictly forbidden in Judaism. This is based on the first two of the Ten Commandments, which prohibits the worship of other gods and the creation of idols.
----------
Does the God of the Torah allow someone to pray to anyone other than Him?
In the Torah, it is made clear that God is a jealous God and commands His followers to worship only Him. This means that praying to anyone other than God goes against the teachings of the Torah. The first of the Ten Commandments states, "You shall have no other gods before me." This commandment emphasizes the importance of worshipping and praying only to God.
Throughout the Torah, there are numerous examples of individuals who strayed from this commandment and worshipped false gods or idols. These actions were always met with consequences from God, as He expects His followers to remain faithful and devoted solely to Him.
Therefore, according to the teachings of the Torah, it is not permissible for someone to pray to anyone other than God. Doing so would be considered idolatry and a violation of one of the fundamental principles of Judaism.
———
Is making intercession to Mary considered as prayer?
Intercession to Mary is a form of prayer in which individuals ask Mary, the mother of Jesus, to intercede on their behalf with God. This practice is common among Catholics and some other Christian denominations who believe in the intercessory power of saints. When someone makes intercession to Mary, they are essentially asking her to pray for them or bring their petitions before God.
This form of prayer is based on the belief that Mary holds a special place in heaven and has a close relationship with God due to her role as the mother of Jesus. By asking for her intercession, believers hope that she will use her influence with God to help them in their time of need.
It's important to note that while making intercession to Mary is considered a form of prayer by those who practice it, it may not be accepted or understood by all Christians. Some denominations do not believe in praying to saints or see it as unnecessary since they believe they can directly communicate with God through Jesus Christ.
